
Alright, alright, National Treasure: Book of Secrets is not the best movie ever made, I know. But that’s what makes it so interesting to analyze.

One problem I think is the actual treasure hunt with its clues. The two pieces of wood are never put together and the divided signs are never read. But Queen Victoria wrote clues in a letter that would have been better off as a result of those signs.
But be as it may with that, I react to the following:
Ben Gates kidnaps the President by cutting him off from his bodyguards. No harm is done to the President and Ben Gates shows him the way out of the tunnels. The President says that if Gates doesn’t find what he is looking for (City of Gold) he will be wanted for kidnapping. Then when Gates actually finds the City of Gold the President says that Gates didn’t kidnap him, but saved him when the door accidentally closed upon them.
There is nothing in this that hinders the President from telling this story from the beginning. The Book of Secrets (the President’s book) is not mentioned in either case.
Of course we need an obstacle and therefore send FBI after Ben Gates, but to make this work really well, we need something that hinders the President from saving Gates’ ass in the first place.
My guess is that the President blackmailed Gates in some earlier draft. Like if Gates could help him with page 47 in the book, then he would call of the hounds. But that would put the President in a strange light. Besides, would Gates really help a corrupted President just to skip jail for himself?
And since the story is so much about honor and American Values the President could not possibly be a shitbag without the story including that he gets exposed as such. It would be a too far complex story, or a completely different story.
Then there is another thing:
In the first movie Ben Gates makes friends (sort of) with FBI agent Sadusky. This is used in the second movie where Gates visits his friend and gets information that he needs.
Then Ben Gates ends up on the top wanted list and Sadusky needs to find and arrest a guy that he come to respect and given information to for that matter.
At the end, all they do is a few lines over a phone: “Are you ready to turn yourself in”, “No, not exactly ... City of Gold … Bla bla bla” “It doesn’t matter. You still committed a federal offence” or something like that.
I would have liked to have something more solid. Like seeing the actual arrest where they meet face to face, coming to conclusions.
And a follow-up of the repeated line from the first movie “someone got to go to prison, Ben” is a must.
And since Ben Gates kidnapped the President, isn’t in likely that they will cuff him? And then Sadusky and Gates with company takes a chopper to where the President can meet up. The President says Gates didn’t kidnap him with a wink to Sadusky, who then unlocks the handcuffs.
My guess is that an ending like this would take too much time. Or is it just me who like Sadusky? I think it would have been nice to have a calm moment between Gates and Sadusky after all the action, just like in the first movie. Something to be used in a third movie, perhaps.
Filmography links and data courtesy of
The Internet Movie Database.
Copyright of movie poster belongs to
the production company